National Planning Systems Between Convergence and Incongruity: Implications for Cross-Border Cooperation from the German-Polish Perspective

Authors:

• Alexander Guido Tölle

Abstract

Convergence of national planning systems in Europe has become an important issue in the context of transnational and cross-border planning, which in turn plays a key role in the policy of creating a cohesive European space. Converging trends concerning planning styles and structures may undoubtedly be detected and also include new European Union (EU) member countries. Yet, by a minute's inspection of the (long-established) German and of the (created in the run-up to EU membership) Polish planning system from a cross-border planning perspective, it becomes obvious that similar structures may not coincide with a similar idea of what spatial planning is about. As highlighted by two chosen examples-cross-border twin-city and metropolitan planning-this results in significant hindrances for planning cooperation in its own right. The article concludes that any convergence of planning systems-if it was to have a constructive impact on cross-border planning-needs to be based on the acceptance of joint planning standards, objectives and values. © 2013 Copyright Taylor and Francis Group, LLC.